Justice Issues...

Sustainable Development

 

"Development that meets the needs of the present without comprising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs"

The Internationally Recognised Definition produced by the World Commission on Environment and Development in 1987

Some Voices

The Challenges

Checklist for the World Leaders

A Quick Look at the UN

Online Resources

 
Some Voices

The Right to Food
- Hungry for what is right (FIAN-Magazine), No. 24/ December 2001

"After decades of growing food availablity there are signs of future scarcity due to ecological constraints and population growth. Studies indicate that resources could neverthless suffice - even without introduction of even more hazardous agricultural technologies such as genetically mutilated food. For this to occur, however, it may be necessary for the rich to drastically reduce their (unhealthy) meat consumption to increase the availablity of cereals for direct consumption: it takes 7 kg of grain to produce 1 kg of beef in a feedlot."

An Arms-Free Environment
- Worldwatch Institute

"The growing number of international environmental treaties and other initiatives suffer from weak commitments and inadequate funding. The U.N. Environment Programme has struggled to maintain its annual budget of roughly $100 million. At the same time, military expenditures by the world's governments are running at more than $2 billion a day."

"In several countries around the developing world, abundant natural resources are at the root of the matter-either triggering violent conflict or financing its continuation. In fact, about a quarter of the 49 wars and armed conflicts waged during 2000 had a strong resource dimension. And many of them are taking place in areas of great environmental value.

In some cases, groups initiate violence to gain and maintain control over lucrative resources. In others, the pillaging of oil, minerals, metals, gemstones, or timber allows wars to continue that were initially caused by other factors, such as unresolved grievances or ideological struggles, as seen in Sierra Leone (diamonds) and Afghanistan (emeralds, lapis lazuli, heroin). Conflict has also erupted in countries such as Columbia (oil) and Indonesia (timber, natural gas), where the benefits accrue to a small elite while the social and environmental burdens are borne by local communities."

Where are Sustainable Indigenous Communities, Where is Sustainable Development
- Indigenous Affairs, 4/01

"Indigenous people are at the cutting edge of the crisis in sustainable development. Their communities are concrete examples of sustainable societies, historically evolved in diverse ecosystems. Today, they face the challenges of extinction or survival and renewal in a globalized world... Indigenous peoples comprise five per cent of the world's population but embody 80 per cent of the world's cultural diversity. They are estimated to occupy 20% of the world's land surface but nurture 80% of the world biodiversity on ancestral lands and territories... The Traditional Native American Farmers Association estimates that Indigenous Peoples cultivated 65% of the crop varieties consumed throughout the world."

 
Why sustainable development has not been achieved in the last ten years?

Following is an extract from "Johannesburg Summit Needs to Highlight Effects of Poverty"
by Jessica Wilson and Stephen Law
The full text was first appeared in Global Dialogue (Volume 6.2, July 2001)
and published by the
Third World Network Features

The key challenge in this rapidly globalising world, which will be echoed at the world summit, is to break the power imbalance that allows exploitation and the abuse of women, children, men, nature, rural communities, and developing countries. This imbalance of power is observable in:

  • Terms of trade that favour rich countries over poor, and which, through controlled access to markets, the control of technology, etc, serve to maintain or deepen that inequality.
  • Debt flows in which billions of dollars flow out of the developing world every year in the form of debt repayments, paying interest upon interest upon interest. Yet the ecological debt incurred by the North and its consumptive lifestyles has never been paid.
  • Flows of development aid from North to South which have declined massively in real terms over the past 10 years. More and more, development aid is being linked to trade agreements invariably loaded in favour of the North; to investment in which substantial profits are paid offshore; to strict conditions that cut state spending on education, health, etc; or allocated to specific 'development' projects such as dams, large agricultural projects, etc, designed and constructed by Northern consultants. More subtly, the intrusion of multinational business into developing countries has disrupted social and cultural traditions based on an understanding of the sustainable use of resources, and supplanted them with inappropriate new habits.
  • Carbon emissions and pollution originating in the developed world yet posing a global threat and leaving developing countries even more vulnerable. If the United States, for example, were to emit its 'fair share' of carbon dioxide while keeping within the 'safe limits' of greenhouse gas emission, it would need to reduce its CO2 emissions by about 90%. At the same time, models predict that the poorer countries are the most vulnerable and the least able to adapted to the negative effects of climate change. It is predicted that southern Africa will be particularly hard hit by climate change.
  • Resource consumption, where a quarter of the world's people consume more than three-quarters of the world's energy, metals and minerals; produce more than 90% of all industrial and hazardous waste; and eat more than half the world's food.
  • Women and children as the primary targets of violence and abuse in developed and developing countries, and are among those who suffer most from poverty, injustice, and underdevelopment. Since 1945, 'superpower' conflict has invariably played itself out in developing countries, from Korea through Vietnam to Afganistan and Somalia. Notwithstanding the direct impact of war on natural systems, these conflicts serve to deepen poverty and disrupt formerly stable social and cultural traditions.
  • International law and institutions whose development has historically been driven and controlled by 'Northern' interests. Even today's generally accepted definition of 'sustainable development' is a Northern product.

It is clear that people in the developing world - both government and non-government - need to be up-front about this: neither development nor environmental protection can take place in a world where a privileged few control access to and the ownership of resources. It is not just about ironing out small problems in international texts, or graciously accepting another sum of 'development' aid with different strings attached. It is about taking the lead and demonstrating that if human beings are to survive as a species, we need to go about managing the world in a very different way.

 
A Checklist for the World Leaders

Vocation for Justice, Summer 2002, Volume 16 No 2

Climate and Energy

  • Recognise carbon debt (i.e. industrialised countries have a historical responsibility to reduce emissions and provide adequate funds to reduce the vulnerability of affected communities).
  • Mandate negotiators in the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change process to define dangerous climate change, accelerate the next round of emissions reductions and move towards a system of safe, global per capita emissions limits.
  • Establish targets and timetables for the rapid deployment of renewable energy and the phase-out of international and domestic fossil fuel subsidies.
  • Immediately stop construction of new nuclear reactors.
  • Stop the reprocessing of plutonium and the production of mixed oxide plutonium fuel.

Forests and Biodiversity

  • Commit to allocate the necessary funds for ancient forest conservation and sustainable use under the Convention on Biological Diversity's forest work programme.
  • Adopt a robust mechanism for establishing certification of legality for timber logging with independent verification.
  • Make it illegal to import illegally sourced timber products.

Genetic Engineering

  • Give priority to agricultural practices that respect traditional knowledge and the environment.
  • Adopt a new instrument to prevent patenting of life and oppose the WTO's TRIPS (Trade-Related Intellectual Property Rights) approach.
  • Ratify the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety.
  • Commit to allowing no irreversible releases of genetically-modified organisms (gmos).
  • Commit to public control of agricultural biodiversity.
  • Provide international support for biodiversity conservation.

Corporate Accountability

  • A legally-binding international treaty which requires international companies, wherever they operate, to adopt best practice in their operations and to be accountable for their environmental and social damage to citizens and communities.

Trade and Food

  • The promotion of food security and non-intensive agriculture are key issues that governments must address through the United Nations.
  • International environmental and social treaties should not be subject to free trade rules and should take precedence over them.
  • The Earth Summit should not promote the WTO's controversial trade-liberalising agenda, but seek new, sustainable economies.

Water

  • International co-operation on freshwater strengthened via an international framework so that water supplies are managed by people, communities and governments at the most suitable local level.

Oceans

  • Moratorium on fishing in areas of high biodiversity.
  • UN General Assembly to establish a conference to negotiate an international agreement for the protection of marine biodiversity.
  • Genetic engineering-free seas - no intentional or unintentional releases of gmos into the marine environment.
  • Agree that WTO must not oppose efforts of regional fisheries management bodies to impose trade restrictions to enhance compliance with multilaterally agreed conservation measures.
  • Deep sea mine tailings disposal should be abolished.

Cities

  • Promote sustainable ecological initiatives in urban areas.

Disarmament

  • Reduce military expenditure in favour of increased expenditure on life-enhancing initiatives.
  • New initiatives on disarmament, in particular in relation to nuclear weapons.
 
A Quick Look

Commission on Sustainable Development (CSD)

  • being created in December 1992 to ensure effective follow-up of the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), to monitor and report on implementation of the agreements at the local, national, regional and international levels
  • a functional commission of the Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC)
  • an inter-governmental body whose members are elected by the ECOSOC from amongst the Member States of the United Nations and its specialized agencies

United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED)
3 to 14 June 1992
Rio de Janerio, Brazil

  • with "Environment and Sustainable Development" as principal theme, governments recognized the need to redirect international and national plans and policies to ensure that all economic decisions fully took into account any environmental impact
  • the Agenda 21 was adopted by the international community
  • the Commission on Sustainable Development was created after this conference for follow-up
  • influenced the subsequent UN conferences, which have examined the relationship between human rights, population, social development, women and human settlements and the need for environmentally sustainable development.

World Summit on Sustainable Development
26 August to 4 September 2002
Johannesburg, South Africa

  • an opportunity for leaders to adopt concrete steps and identify quantifiable targets for better implementing Agenda 21 ten years after the UNCED
  • will be participated by governments and representatives from the Major Groups identified in Agenda 21
  • started the preparation process in 2001 in 2 steps, including:
    1 - a comprehensive "Assessment" by all actors, identifying progress and obstacles to the process of achieving sustainable development
    2 - a new comprehensive "Programme of Action" developed by all actors for the next ten years (2002-2012)

Agenda 21

  • a comprehensive plan of action to be taken at all levels by organizations of the UN system, governments, and major groups in every area in which human impacts on the environment
  • consists of 27 principles addressing a wide range of issues including poverty, hunger, disease, illiteracy and environmental degradations as a set of interrelated issues
  • recognises women, children and youth, business and industry, workers and trade unions, NGOs, the science and technology community, local authorities, farmers and indigenous as 'major groups' who play crucial role in achieving sustainable development
 
More Online Resources

Sustainable Social Development in a Period of Rapid Globalisation:
Challenges, Opportunities and Policy Options

is a study conducted by the UN Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP). It looks at the aspects of social development that are thought to have some linkages with the process of globalisation. The study reflects the core goals of social development as identified by the World Summit for Social Development, the global opportunities as well as the social risks and challenges to the realisation of these goals.

State of the World 2002
is a report released by the Worldwatch Institute with focus on issues central to the UN World Summit on Sustainable Development in August 2002. It highlights social and environmental advances as well as negative trends since the Earth Summit in 1992. The report also points to several significant impediments that have slowed progress towards building a sustainable world over the last decade.

Human Rights in Development
is the web site of Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, where the indivisible link between human rights and development, which is an important key to achieve sustainable development is explained.

Stakeholder Forum
is an international multi-stakeholder organisation - a network and forum on sustainable development which has promoted outcomes from the first Earth Summit in 1992 and is now working on preparations for
Earth Summit 2002.

Peoples-Earth-Summit
is a place for sharing your events and organisational details and links online for the Earth Summit. It aims to inspire diverse individuals and organisations to join forces in strengthening and developing initiatives, policies and legislation which will scale up sustainable and healthy ways of living for humanity and the planet.

Sustainable Development and the Environment in East Timor
is the proceeding of the Conference on Sustainable Development organised by the
Timor Aid, held in Dili on 25-31 January 2001. It publishes the presentations made at the conference, which provide an overview of sustainable development issues in East Timor 18 months after the total destruction of infrastructure, and 18 months into the complex process of nation building. A list of organisations, strategies and directories is especially helpful for getting more information on this topic.

Greenpeace
Greenpeace is a non-profit organisation, with a presence in 40 countries across Europe, the Americas, Asia and the Pacific. It focuses on the the most crucial worldwide threats to our planet's biodiversity and environment.

Christian Ecology Link (CEL)
is a multi denominational UK Christian movement for people concerned about the Environment.