Hotline Asia Urgent Appeals -- UA981201(8)

Killing and Torture with of Alleged NPA Members
~ PHILIPPINES ~
1 December 1998

Action Requested || Sample Letter || Background

 

Summary

Once again serious human rights violations have occurred and the military in the Philippines have justified their actions on the alleged continued threat from the New People's Army (NPA, the military wing of the outlawed Communist Party of the Philippines or CPP). Mr. Roberto Bornales, a fisherman of Espanola, Palawan Province, was killed by the members of the Philippines Armed Forces, while another, Mr. Abe Sungit, a farmer from Espanola was arrested and tortured.

 
Action Requested

Please write polite letters to Government of the Republic of the Philippines expressing:
1. your concern about the extra-judicial execution of Mr. Roberto Bornales;
2. your concern about the arbitrary arrest and torture of Mr. Abe Sungit;
3. the opinion that:
* the military should not carry out extra-judicial execution, arbitrary arrests or detention;
* suspects should not be subjected to any form of torture during arrest and detention;
* suspects should not be forced to sign any documents; and
* those responsible for the above atrocities should be brought to justice.

SEND LETTERS TO

President Joseph "Erap" Estrada
Malacanang Palace, Manila, Philippines
Fax: 63-2-731 1325

c.c. copies to:
1. Diplomatic Representatives of the Philippines accredited to your country.

 

Sample Letter

We are shocked and deeply concerned about the arbitrary treatment of Mr. Roberto Bornales and Mr. Abe Sungit in Palawan province. Sadly, Bornales was shot dead and Sungit detained, subjected to torture. Sungit will be charged with rebellion. The military made use of their authority and carried out these atrocities over innocent people. As the families of the victims have said, Bornales and Sungit were both common fisherman and farmer respectively who did not participate in any activities which could be defined as "rebellion". The military did not provide any form of provocation or evidence when they fired on the two and made the arrest. We urged the government and officials to conduct impartial and swift investigations into the matter and bring those responsible to justice.
 

Background

(I) SHOOTING DEAD OF BORNALES
On 19th October 1998, Mr. Roberto Bornales, 38, was shot dead by soldiers belonging to the 1st Marine Battalion of the Armed Forces of the Philippines. The commanding officer of the Marines said that Bornales was a NPA member who engaged his forces in an armed encounter in the province of Palawan. At the time, Mr. Abe Sungit was accompanying Bornales to visit their tribal leader at Sitio Ganawang, in the mountains of Espanola, Palawan province to discuss harvest matters. Sungit witnessed the killing of Bornales by the soldiers which happened without any provocation. Bornales died immediately and Sungit was arrested.

Bornales' wife, Helen, told the media that her husband was not a NPA member but only the organizer of a fisherfolks association and was not involved in any acts of military rebellion as alleged by the Marine commanding officer.

(II) SUNGIT SUBJECTED TO TORTURE
After the killing of Bornales, Sungit was then arbitrarily arrested by the military. On the way to detention, the soldiers kicked his stomach and hit his back several times. When he was brought to the Marines headquarters in Barangay Abo-abo, his captors tied his hands with rope and subjected him to serious beatings while interrogating him. Sungit reported that he was forced to sign a document claiming ownership of a shotgun which was then used as evidence to prove his membership of the NPA. He is detained in Palawan provincial jail and facing a charge of rebellion.

Sungit's father insists that his son was a farmer in the area of Espanola. Sungit is a member of an indigenous community in Palawan.

(III) CONFLICTS BETWEEN THE TRIBALS AND THE MILITARY
Palawan province (a group of islands located in the southwest of the Philippines archipelago) is rich in natural resources. These are found offshore and in many mineral deposits on the islands. A few years ago, investors started to find it profitable to set up business in Palawan and had plans to build plant there. These plans are a threat to the indigenous inhabitants and ecological environment of Palawan. Environmental conservationists and human rights groups took up the cause of the indigenous inhabitants and the environment, successfully stopping some of these plans.

At the same time, under the pretext thart NPA forces have increased by 280 percent, the military have increased their activities on the island. However, these activities seen to mainly consist of the arbitrary treatment of indigenous, environmental and human rights activists. Human rights groups believe that the military's actions are mainly aimed at intimidating the opposition to business interests.

 

Please remember to send copies of your letters to Hotline Asia for monitoring purpose.
Thank you for Your Continued Support!!